Cucumis - Senkotiza tradukservo interrete
. .



Traduko - Latina lingvo-Angla - Sortitus erat a natura nobiles ad laudem impetus,...

Nuna statoTraduko
Tiu teksto haveblas en la sekvaj lingvoj: Latina lingvoAnglaFranca

Kategorio Literaturo - Societo / Popolo / Politiko

Titolo
Sortitus erat a natura nobiles ad laudem impetus,...
Teksto
Submetigx per jude-off
Font-lingvo: Latina lingvo

Sortitus erat a natura nobiles ad laudem impetus, sed quia doctrina non accessit, irae impotens, obstinataeque pervicaciae fuit.
Rimarkoj pri la traduko
Voila, je reprends la lecture de l'abbé Lhomond histoire de me remettre dans le bain du latin !
Ici pas d'ambiguité, mais je n'arrive pas bien à traduire, il s'agit de la vie de Coriolan. J'ai déjà le début ("il était par le sort de nature noble...") mais le laudem me gène vraiment..
Merci d'avance

Titolo
He had received from a nature noble zeals ...
Traduko
Angla

Tradukita per Aneta B.
Cel-lingvo: Angla

He had received from nature noble zeals for glory, but because he didn't succeed in studying, no having control over his anger, he was filled by a never-ending stubbornness.
Rimarkoj pri la traduko
he didn't succeed in stydying = he wasn't good at studying = he didn't learn well /literally: he didn't achieve this (the glory) by a study

he was full of a never-ending stubbornness = he remained permanently stubborn / heated
Laste validigita aŭ redaktita de lilian canale - 9 Novembro 2009 20:29





Lasta Afiŝo

Aŭtoro
Afiŝo

5 Novembro 2009 16:07

tarinoidenkertoja
Nombro da afiŝoj: 113
I know I m a bit irritating But I don t agree with the translation (apart about that "sortitus erat" related part) for several reasons:
you have translated "irae impotens" in the same way as an absolute ablative. In my opinion here "irae impotens " is a consequence of "quia doctrina accessit" not a concurring cause.
With "doctrina" I think he intends "the knowledge of military tactics" , I ve read the following part of his book and it quotes the habit that Coriolanus had to not come back from battles without a military decoration.That s the "laudem".
And however I still think that a translation of "sortitus erat a natura " as "he was moved by nature to noble efforts to glory/merit" would fit more.

5 Novembro 2009 18:46

Aneta B.
Nombro da afiŝoj: 4487
Your proposition: "he was moved by nature to noble efforts to glory/merit"
My proposition: "He had received from a nature noble zeals for a glory"

Sorry but I can't see any big difference in a meaning of these sentences... They mean the same. Of course, we can sometimes replace an active voice by a passive voice translating from Latin... And THIS your proposition is also acceptable, but I've chosen the active version, because it is closer to the original in its grammatical structure. That's all...

"irae impotens". I didn't translate it as Abl. Absolutus.
impotens - disable of sth... in this case: of anger (irae). (=iram tenere non potest)

5 Novembro 2009 18:50

Aneta B.
Nombro da afiŝoj: 4487
AND "STUDING" of course can be "studing of military tactics"... but it is only default meaning which has to stay in our mind only...

5 Novembro 2009 19:31

lilian canale
Nombro da afiŝoj: 14972
Hi Aneta,
I think Tarino's version is more understandable and correct in English. Your sentence is faulty.
"glory" and "nature" are uncountable nouns.
"wasn't succeed" is also wrong and there are a couple of misspellings.

5 Novembro 2009 19:37

Aneta B.
Nombro da afiŝoj: 4487
Yes, "glory" and "nature" are uncountable nouns... I don't know what you mean typing it Lilly... Did I use the nouns in a wrong way? Should they be without "a"?

wasn't succed --?> didn't succeed. Will be ok?

If you think it is still uncorrect, just reject it. I don't claim my English is perfect.

5 Novembro 2009 19:48

lilian canale
Nombro da afiŝoj: 14972
I meant that uncountable nouns can't be preceded by "a" like you wrote: "from a nature", "for a glory"

wasn't successful
didn't succeed

"...he was full of a persistent stubborness." sounds awkward. "he was filled by a never-ending stubborness" would sound better.


5 Novembro 2009 20:15

Aneta B.
Nombro da afiŝoj: 4487
Are you sure about stubborness instead of stubbornnes? My two dictionaries show sth different...?


5 Novembro 2009 20:20

lilian canale
Nombro da afiŝoj: 14972
Ops! I mixed up words (with 'stubbornest'), sorry. I think I need a break

5 Novembro 2009 20:22

Aneta B.
Nombro da afiŝoj: 4487
That's ok, Lilly. I can understand. I'm also tired nowadays...

So, I will edit the translation according to the rest of your suggestions in a moment...