Cucumis - निशुल्क अन्-लाइन अनुबाद सेवा
. .



अनुबाद - Indonesian-अंग्रेजी - indonesia......

अहिलेको अवस्थाअनुबाद
यो हरफ निम्न भाषामा उपलब्ध छ: Indonesianअंग्रेजीस्पेनी

Category Chat - Daily life

This translation request is "Meaning only".
शीर्षक
indonesia......
हरफ
Malleaद्वारा बुझाइएको
स्रोत भाषा: Indonesian

hai cantik kamu bisa bahasa indonesia gak? kamu tahu indonesia kan?

शीर्षक
Hello, beautiful. You speak ...
अनुबाद
अंग्रेजी

gbernsdorffद्वारा अनुबाद गरिएको
अनुबाद गर्नुपर्ने भाषा: अंग्रेजी

Hello, beautiful. You speak Indonesian, don't you?
Do you know Indonesia?
Validated by lilian canale - 2009年 अक्टोबर 18日 16:05





पछिल्ला सन्देशहरु

लेखक
सन्देश

2009年 अक्टोबर 2日 12:06

gbernsdorff
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 240
Did I write *Have you been to ...* ??? Or did someone change it into that? Anyway, that is not exactly what *kamu tahu ..* means.
On second thoughts, the better translation is *Hello, beautiful. You speak Indonesian, don't you? Do you know Indonesia?*
[*Have you been to...* would be *Kamu pernah ke...*]
I am sorry for the trouble.

2009年 अक्टोबर 2日 12:54

lilian canale
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 14972
Hi Guido,
I made the edit. In English you don't usually ask "Do you know...?" referring to a place. The most usual wording is "Have you (ever) been to...? even if that has a different structure in other languages.

2009年 अक्टोबर 6日 02:28

Mallea
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 5
thank you both

2009年 अक्टोबर 7日 17:09

gbernsdorff
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 240
Sorry for the long wait. I am afraid I can't agree with the edit. "Have you been to..." is far too restricted an interpretation of the source text. "Tahu Indonesia kan?" is primarily asking if a person has any knowledge ABOUT the country. In other words: it is a question to which one can very well answer "yes", even if one has never been to Indonesia. To be quite sure I have checked this with a Scotsman (a boyhood chum of mine) and with my British neighbour, who has lived in Malaysia for a while.

2009年 अक्टोबर 7日 17:24

lilian canale
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 14972
In that case, I think that in order to be clear, it should read:
"Do you know (anything) about/of Indonesia?"

2009年 अक्टोबर 7日 21:38

gbernsdorff
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 240
Hello Lilian,
I may not have been clear enough myself, sorry for that.
I do not want my translation to be clear, not in that sense, not unequivocal.
If you go for either *Have you been to Indonesia?* or *Do you know anything about Indonesia?* you are making a definite choice between two possible interpretations of the question.

Of three translations presented so far, only *Do you know Indonesia?* leaves room for ambiguity. It is the only one that primarily asks for *knowledge of*, then leaves some room for the other interpretation that came to your mind (*Have you been there*), and that is exactly what *kamu tahu indonesia kan?* does. Therefore, I think that it is the only translation that adequately conveys the meaning of the source text.
Guido

2009年 अक्टोबर 7日 21:57

lilian canale
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 14972
It's too bad we don't have any expert for Indonesian to help us here.
For what you posted above your intention (or the intention in the original) is leaving a doubt about the meaning of the line by using "Do you know Indonesia"?

2009年 अक्टोबर 7日 23:22

gbernsdorff
चिठ्ठीको सङ्ख्या: 240
Too bad indeed. I have checked with my partner (not a member of Cucumis), who is a native speaker, if that is any help :-)
However, I speak Indonesian Malay well enough myself to be sure about this: *kamu tahu indonesia kan?* can be interpreted both ways. Just which way any person will interpret it will depend on what has been said earlier in the conversation, or the circumstances leading up to it. Therefore, without such context, the meaning IS BOUND TO leave some doubt. I do want to preserve that ambiguity, for it is inherent to the wording of the Indonesian text. Any English text that lacks this ambiguity cannot claim to be an adequate translation.
"Do you know…" functions exactly the same way as "Kamu tahu Indonesia kan". Standing by itself, it does not give you a clue. It leaves some doubt, as it SHOULD do.
If you google for "Do you know Germany?" or "Do you know France?" you will find that the context may make its meaning clear:
Do You Know Germany? is a brochure for students of all ages.
Do you know Germany, eh? Watch our video clips . Read the info texts on Germany. Then you'll be ready to tackle our QUIZ.
Do you know Germany? Capital, Major Cities, and Tourist Attractions. Geography.
Do you know Germany? Do you have some suggestions for other visitors?
Do you know France? Any particular favourite parts?
Do you know France? If so, which region?
How well do you know France? Test your knowledge of France in this short quiz.
I saw that you went to England and Canada. Do you know France?